MLM Recruiters Overpromise Income, and Most Recruits Lose Money
TL;DR
- •$225 million: Settlement with Amway and two affiliates, announced by the FTC on September 17, 2026, which the FTC describes as the largest monetary recovery in an FTC action against a multilevel marketing company.
- •$40,000: Annual income the FTC alleges Amway's affiliates told prospective recruits they were likely to earn.
- •70%: Share of purchased products participants must sell to others each month under the proposed order.
Stay curious
One problem,
every Tuesday.
The most interesting problem of the week, straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Want the deeper version?
Problem Desk
Problem Desk is the tracked, ongoing version — scored, sourced, and re-verified over time.
Explore Problem DeskWhat the FTC alleges
On September 17, 2026, the FTC and the State of Washington filed a complaint against Amway and two of its affiliates, World Wide Group and Leadership Team Development. The complaint alleges that the affiliates told prospective recruits they were likely to earn substantial income, exceeding $40,000 a year.
The central allegation is about results, not just promises. According to the complaint, most people who joined WWG or LTD after 2020 spent more money on Amway products and training than they received from Amway. Those are the people the case is about.
These are allegations in a proposed settlement, not findings from a trial. The FTC describes them as the basis for the settlement, and the proposed order is what the agreement would require.
What the proposed order requires
According to the FTC, the proposed order requires participants to sell to others at least 70% of the products they purchase from Amway each month. It also bars approved recruiting groups, including WWG and LTD, from charging new participants for any training or services during their first year.
The order applies to Amway and these affiliates. It does not set rules for the MLM industry as a whole. Other companies using a similar recruiting model are not covered by this settlement.
Why the buying-and-selling gap is the core issue
The complaint's central problem is the gap between what a recruit spends and what they can recover. A participant who buys product each month, pays for training, and sells little to customers has money going out and little coming in. That is the pattern the complaint describes when it says most recruits spent more than they received.
The 70% resale requirement addresses that gap directly. If participants must sell most of what they buy to actual customers, product purchases are tied to real sales rather than to keeping a position in the group. This is an inference from the order's structure, not a finding the FTC states in these terms, but it explains why the resale rule is the central remedy.
Why this matters beyond one case
The FTC describes the $225 million figure as the largest monetary recovery in an FTC action against a multilevel marketing company. Amway reports more than 290,000 Independent Business Owners on its website, so the group of people affected by the company's recruiting practices is large.
Anyone considering a recruiting program is most likely to hear the income claim before they join, which is why the complaint focuses on it. The settlement does not tell a prospect what a given program will pay them. It tells them what one company was alleged to have promised, and what the FTC found most recruits from one group experienced.
Proof signals
FTC press release, September 17, 2026. The primary source for the $225 million figure, the $40,000 allegation, the finding about recruits who joined WWG or LTD after 2020, the 70% resale requirement, and the first-year fee restriction. It also includes a statement from the Bureau of Consumer Protection director on the misleading earnings claims.
KOMO News, October 2026. Reports Amway's own figure of more than 290,000 Independent Business Owners and covers the Washington State participation in the settlement. Use it for the company's count, not for the FTC's findings.
What to actually do about it
Before joining any recruiting program, do the arithmetic that the complaint describes:
- Ask for earnings data for the typical participant. Look for the median or the share of participants who made money, not the top earners in the company's marketing.
- Ask what a new participant is expected to spend in year one. Include product purchases, training, and fees. If the total is not written down, treat that as the answer.
- Check how much of the product gets sold to customers. The FTC's resale rule exists because product that is only bought by participants is not a retail business. Ask how much of the inventory is sold outside the group.
Before you decide, ask:
- Will the court enter the proposed order in its current form, and will the 70% resale requirement change how much product participants buy?
- How many participants who joined WWG or LTD after 2020 will receive a refund, and how will that amount be calculated?
- Does a settlement covering Amway's two largest recruiting affiliates change how other MLM companies disclose earnings to recruits?
Stay curious
One problem,
every Tuesday.
The most interesting problem of the week, straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Want the deeper version?
Problem Desk
Problem Desk is the tracked, ongoing version — scored, sourced, and re-verified over time.
Explore Problem DeskSources
Related Problems
66% of Companies Know Human-AI Collaboration Matters but Only 6% Are Doing It
Two out of three organizations say that designing how humans and AI agents work together is important, according to [Deloitte's 2026 Global Human Capital Trends](https://www.deloit...
Cold Email's Strict Reply Rate Is 0.45%, and AI Spam Is Why
[Belkins](https://belkins.io/blog/cold-email-response-rates) measured 7.5 million cold emails sent in 2025 and found a strict reply rate of 0.45%, counting replies against every em...
Medical Bills Hide Fees Until After the Care Is Delivered
On October 5, 2026, the FTC sent warning letters to 24 healthcare services companies. The letters say that failing to give patients timely, accurate, and complete pricing for healt...